Health Encyclopedia

 

Health Encyclopedia Home



Slow Eating Might Help Curb Calories

Slow Eating Might Help Curb Calories

THURSDAY, Jan. 2, 2014 (HealthDay News) -- As people look for fresh strategies to cut back on calories and shed pounds, a new study suggests that simply eating more slowly can significantly reduce how much people eat in a single sitting.

The study involved a small group of both normal-weight and obese or overweight participants. All were given an opportunity to eat a meal under relaxed, slow-speed conditions, and then in a time-constrained, fast-speed environment.

The catch: Although all participants consumed less when eating slowly and all said they felt less hungry after eating a slow meal compared to a fast meal, only people who were considered normal weight actually reduced their calorie intake significantly when eating more slowly.

"One possible reason [for the calorie drop seen] may be that slower eating allows people to better sense their feelings of hunger and fullness," said study author Meena Shah, a professor in the department of kinesiology at Texas Christian University, in Fort Worth.

Slow eating also seemed to increase water intake and stomach swelling, Shah said, while also affecting the biological process that determines how much food people consume.

The study was published online Jan. 2 in the Journal of the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics.

Although just less than 15 percent of Americans were obese in the early 1970s, that figure increased to nearly 36 percent by 2010, the researchers said.

To explore a potential connection between slow eating and reduced caloric intake, the team focused on 35 normal-weight men and women and 35 overweight or obese men and women.

During a two-day study period, all were asked to consume the exact same meals under two conditions. The "slow" meal was spread over an average of 22 minutes per meal, involving small bites and deliberate chewing without concern for time. The "fast" meal involved large bites and quick chewing, under the notion that time was of the essence. The average fast-meal time was about nine minutes.

The result: Normal-weight participants were found to consume 88 fewer calories when eating slowly, a decrease deemed "significant." By contrast, the obese/overweight group saw only a 58-calorie reduction during the slow-eating session, which was not considered significant.

The researchers said the obese/overweight group actually consumed less food overall during both the slow- and fast-eating sessions than the normal-weight group. That finding might explain the smaller calorie drop during the first group's slow-eating trial, they said.

Some self-consciousness among the participants might also have affected eating patterns, leading them to consume food in a manner that differed from a private, real-world setting. "There is always the possibility that people will eat differently when they are being observed," Shah said.

Both groups ate less when eating slowly, however, and a notable spike in water intake during the slow-eating test might be a major reason why. When eating slowly, water intake increased by 27 percent among the normal-weight group, and by 33 percent among the overweight/obese group.

Susan Roberts, a senior scientist with the U.S. Department of Agriculture, suggested that the study suffers from a number of analytic flaws.

"First of all, slow eating reduces [calorie] intake by 10 percent in the normal-weight folk and 8 percent in the obese ones," said Roberts, who works at the nutrition research center at Tufts University in Medford, Mass. "The 10 percent is [deemed] statistically significant, whereas the 8 percent is not. However, there is no significant difference between 8 percent and 10 percent, meaning ... there is no difference in the effect of eating speed on [calorie] intake according to whether you are obese or lean."

"More importantly," she added, "the obese individuals in the study substantially under-ate during the measurements, which calls into question whether the results are meaningful and repeatable."

Lona Sandon, assistant professor of clinical nutrition at the University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center at Dallas, said the study did not control for a number of factors that could have influenced the findings. That makes it impossible to conclude that there is any direct cause and effect between slower eating and lower food consumption, she said.

"However, there are other theories and camps of research that support the theory that we consume less when we eat more slowly," said Sandon, a registered dietitian. "Taking time to enjoy and be more mindful of the food we are eating is associated with eating less."

"[But] it may be a better strategy for preventing weight gain, as opposed to treating overweight and obesity," Sandon said.

More information

To learn more about healthy weight, visit the U.S. National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute.

SOURCES: Meena Shah, Ph.D., professor, department of kinesiology, Texas Christian University, Fort Worth; Lona Sandon, R.D., assistant professor, clinical nutrition, University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center at Dallas; Susan Roberts, Ph.D., senior scientist, USDA Human Nutrition Research Center, Tufts University, Medford, Mass.; Jan, 2, 2014, Journal of the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics, online

 
Related Items
Wellness Library
  Why It May Be Time to Throw Away Your Scale
  What's Your Healthy Weight?
Quizzes
  Older, Wiser, Wider?
  Weighty Questions
Calculators
  Adult Body Mass Tool
  Children's Body Mass Index
Daily News Feed
  Transplant May Boost Survival in Obese Kidney Failure Patients
  Obese Applicants More Often Denied Entry to Graduate Schools: Study
  Skipping Breakfast May Not Lead to Weight Gain After All
  Urging Your Partner to Diet May Backfire
  'Fat Letters' Take the Stage in Childhood Obesity Debate
  Brain Size May Yield Clues to Anorexia
  Study May Explain Why Some Obese People Don't Get Diabetes
  Your Gut Bacteria May Predict Your Obesity Risk
  Short Bouts of Brisk Exercise May Help Cut Obesity Risk
  Changes in Household Routines Help Reduce Kids' Obesity: Study
  5 Percent of U.S. Kids 'Severely Obese,' Experts Warn
  4 Factors Predict Diabetes Remission After Surgery: Study
  Childhood Obesity Quadruples Chances of Adult Hypertension: Study
  Abnormal BMI Tips Scale Toward Pregnancy Complications, Study Says
  10 Percent Weight Loss May Relieve Arthritic Knee Pain
  Could Obesity Help Older People With Type 2 Diabetes?
  Docs Urged to Treat Unhealthy Habits Before Damage Is Done
  Tom Hanks Has Type 2 Diabetes
  Overweight Teen Years Tied to Later Cancer Risk
  Lower Smog Levels Tied to Lower Birth Weights
  Study: Vitamin D Supplements May Not Raise Risk for Kidney Stones
  Just 12 Percent of Women Over 50 Are 'Satisfied' With Their Bodies
  Early Periods May Signal Greater Diabetes Risk, Study Suggests
  Gene Mutation Tied to Higher Obesity Risk in Kids
  Weight-Loss Surgery Seems to Beat Diet and Exercise
  Smaller Belly, Less Deli May Reduce Kidney Disease Risk, Study Finds
  Overweight Men May Face Higher Death Risk From Prostate Cancer: Study
  Weight-Loss Surgery Safe for Very Obese Teens, Study Says
  Obesity Is Driving Surge in Knee Replacements, Study Finds
  Fewer Pounds May Lead to Better Sex, Researchers Say
  Testing for Pregnancy-Linked Diabetes Should Be Routine, Experts Say
  More Evidence Ties Obesity to Disability in Older Women
  Study Ties Weight-Loss Surgery to Higher Risk of Preemie Birth
  Weight Loss Can Combat Irregular Heart Beat, Study Says
  Texting Your Way to Weight Loss
  PTSD Might Lead to Sizable Weight Gain in Women
  Parents Who Set, Stick to Rules May Help Kids Stay Slim
  Could Good Manners Help Spur Holiday Weight Gain?
  Might Stomach Artery Treatment Be Future Weight-Loss Tool?
  Exercise May Not Stave Off Holiday Weight Gain
  'Healthy Obesity' Is a Myth, Report Says
  Good Body Image Goes Hand in Hand With Happier Relationship
  Take Talk of Weight Off the Holiday Menu
  Kids' Movies Deliver Mixed Messages on Eating, Obesity
  Ear Acupuncture May Hold Promise for Weight Loss
  As Body Weight Rises, So Do Health Costs, Study Finds
  Many Hispanic Women Unaware of Heart Disease Risk Factors
  Whites More Likely to Undergo Weight-Loss Surgery: Study
  Women More Open to Weight-Loss Surgery
  Teen Boys Who Think They're Skinny May Be at Higher Risk for Depression
  Don't Pressure Preschoolers to Overeat, Experts Say
  As Weight Rises in People With Diabetes, So Does Death Risk: Study
  Americans Eating Better, Cutting Calories: USDA
  Kids Bullied During Gym Class May Stop Exercising
  Type 2 Diabetes Is Often a Family Affair
  'Gastric Banding' Patients Often Have Dietary Issues, Study Finds
  Many Parents of Obese Children Underestimate Their Weight
  Shivering, Like Exercise, May Help Boost Weight Loss
  'Fat Hormone' Tied to Higher Colon Cancer Risk in Obese Men
  Sex Is Important to Many Midlife Women
  Obesity's Link to Type 2 Diabetes Not So Clear-Cut: Study
  A Judgmental Doctor May Make It Hard to Lose Weight
  A Little Weight Loss May Ease Sleep Apnea
  C-Section Birth May Raise Risk of Adult Obesity: Study
  U.S. Obesity Rate Shows Signs of Leveling Off
  'Eating for Two' During Pregnancy Could Pack on Too Many Pounds
  Early Signs That High-Calorie Diet May Help With Lou Gehrig's Disease
  Lack of Sleep Compounds Health Problems for Obese Teens: Study
  Women Born Small May Be at Risk of Infertility, Study Suggests
  Obese Girls Prone to Poorer Grades, Study Suggests
  Pain Can Plague Women After Knee Replacement Surgery
  Wider Waistline May Mean Shorter Lifespan: Study
  Weight Loss May Boost Success of Joint-Replacement Surgery
  TV, Computer Time Tied to Heavier, Less Happy Kids: Study
  Genes May Influence Weight Gain From Fried Foods: Study
  Higher Dose of IVF Drug May Be Needed for Obese Women
  Moms Who Keep 'Baby Weight' May Risk Heart Trouble
  'Grazing' Appears No Better for Weight Loss Than Standard Meals
  Weight-Loss Surgery Cuts Risk for Heart Attack, Death: Study
  Underweight Even Deadlier Than Overweight, Study Says
  College Football Players Have Stiffer Arteries, Study Finds
  The Morning Light May Help You Stay Slim
  Teens' Indoor Tanning May Be Linked to Unhealthy Dieting
  Does Facebook Make Women Feel Bad About Their Bodies?
  Low Birth Weight, Lack of Breast-Feeding Tied to Inflammation Risk in Adulthood
  Obesity Linked to Increased Odds of Losing Baby, Study Finds
  Tonsillectomy May Spur Weight Gain in Kids, But Won't Cause Obesity: Study
  Size of Fetus May Affect Stillbirth Risk
  Severe Obesity in Teens Tied to Possible Kidney Problems
  More Muscle May Help Kidney Dialysis Patients
  Glaucoma Drug May Help Reverse Obesity-Related Vision Loss
  Kids' Genetic Risk for Obesity Rises With Age, Study Finds
  Calling Young Girls 'Fat' May Increase Their Teen-Obesity Risk
  Is Healthy Obesity a Myth?
  Weight-Loss Surgery May Help Prevent Heart Rhythm Disorder
  Many Pets Are Too Plump
  Losing Weight at Any Age May Help the Heart
  Fit Kids Have Better Body-Fat Distribution, Study Finds
  Cheaper Food May Be Fueling U.S. Obesity Epidemic
  U.S. Teens' Cardiorespiratory Fitness Has Dropped in Last Decade: Report
  Obesity Crisis Has Scaled Even the Himalayas
  Could White Bread Be Making You Fat?
  Fast Weight Loss May Mean Muscle Loss
  Sagging Eyelids More Common in Men, Fair-Skinned and Overweight: Study
  Diabetes Drug May Spur Weight Loss in Obese Nondiabetics
  'Walkable' Neighborhoods May Help Cut Diabetes Rates
  Weight Gain From Antidepressants Is Minimal, Study Suggests
  Kids' Obesity Risk Rises With Parents' Divorce: Study
  Weight-Loss Surgery May Ease Type 2 Diabetes Long-Term
  When School's Out, Weight Can Pile On
  Can Weight-Loss Surgery Lower Cancer Risk for the Obese?
  FDA Panel Backs Appetite-Curbing Implant for Severely Obese
  Grief in Pregnancy May Trigger Obesity in Adulthood
  FDA: Bee Pollen Weight Loss Products Pose Health Risks
  Fruits, Veggies Not a Magic Bullet for Weight Loss, Study Finds
  Many Obese Women Face Stigma Every Day, Study Finds
  Health Tip: Watching Your Weight During Pregnancy
  Obesity May Raise Risk of COPD
  Inactivity May Be Main Culprit in Obesity Epidemic: Study
  Obesity Epidemic Hitting Hispanics Hard, Study Finds
  Will You Be Obese? Look at Your Sisters, Brothers
  Losing Weight May Ease Hot Flashes, Study Finds
  60 Percent of Diners Use Calorie Labeling When Posted: CDC
  Stress May Leave You Heading to the Cookie Jar
  Exercise May Help Counter Health Risks of Sedentary Lifestyle
  Is Obesity an Advantage After Heart Procedures?