Health Encyclopedia


Health Encyclopedia Home

Jury Still Out on Benefits of Vitamin D

Jury Still Out on Benefits of Vitamin D

TUESDAY, April 1, 2014 (HealthDay News) -- Two new reports that analyzed research on vitamin D supplements found there's no reason to get excited yet about any possible health benefits.

One review, from international researchers, found hardly any benefit. The other analysis suggested it may have what a specialist called a "huge" effect on lifespan, but the findings aren't definitive.

"For now, the vitamin D story is intriguing," said Naveed Sattar, a professor of metabolic medicine at the University of Glasgow in Scotland, who co-wrote an editorial accompanying the studies. But more research is required before any definitive recommendations should be made, he said, since "there may yet be unexpected risks to supplementation."

There's been intense debate about the value of vitamin D supplements in recent years, specifically over whether they contribute to better health.

In one of the new reports, researcher Evropi Theodoratou, at the University of Edinburgh in Scotland, and colleagues examined a series of studies and found that scientists had only examined vitamin D's effects on 10 health issues, a far cry from the 137 that have been linked to vitamin D.

They found only one "benefit" from the vitamin, a seeming link between vitamin D levels late in pregnancy and the birth weight of children. The review also raised questions about whether vitamin D is as important as previously believed when it comes to bone health.

The other new report, from Oscar Franco, at Erasmus University Medical Center Rotterdam, in the Netherlands, and colleagues looked at studies analyzing links between vitamin D and the likelihood that subjects would die during the study follow-up periods of three to seven years.

Together, 14 of the most reliable studies -- known as randomized controlled trials -- linked vitamin D3 supplements to an 11 percent reduction in risk of death. However, there was a slight increase in the death rate among those who took vitamin D2 supplements.

The 11 percent reduction in the death rate "seems remarkable," Sattar and a colleague wrote in their editorial. In an interview, he said the reduction is "huge," potentially putting vitamin D deficiency in the same health-harming league as smoking and physical inactivity.

However, the studies are relatively small and mostly look at the elderly, Sattar noted.

The whole picture is complicated, he said. "There is an assumption that low blood vitamin D levels are causing or contributing to risk for many diseases but recent research tells us that, in fact, the opposite is the case and that having the disease in first place leads to people having low vitamin D levels," he said.

"Furthermore, many of the risk factors which cause disease -- namely, obesity, smoking and poor diet, can also lower vitamin D levels, and it is these risk factors and not necessarily the low vitamin D we need to correct," Sattar said. "To resolve these issues, we need big trials to tell us once and for all whether vitamin D supplements make any difference to health."

When it comes to taking vitamin D supplements, "the best advice is to wait for study findings to be reported," a process that should only take a few more years since a big study will be finished by 2017, he said.

The Council for Responsible Nutrition, which represents the supplement industry, issued a statement on the findings Tuesday.

"As we've seen in other studies, there is something about certain diseases that seems to either be depleting the body of normal levels of vitamin D, or the low levels are contributing to the disease," said Duffy MacKay, senior vice president for scientific and regulatory affairs at the council. "In either case, where patients present with insufficient levels of this critical nutrient, supplementing with vitamin D makes sense -- whether it actually slows the progression of the disease or rather helps to replace the depleted nutrient levels being caused by the disease."

MacKay went on to say that in its "latest review of vitamin D, the Institute of Medicine [a scientific advisory board to the U.S. government] raised the recommended levels for vitamin D."

He added: "In a recently released proposed rule from the U.S. Food & Drug Administration on nutrition and supplements facts labels, the agency identified vitamin D as a 'nutrient of public health significance,' advising that vitamin D content be listed on food labels."

Lona Sandon, an assistant professor of nutrition at University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center at Dallas and a spokeswoman for the American Dietetic Association, said the recommended amount of vitamin D per day for people aged 1 to 70 is 600 international units. It jumps to 800 IU after age 70.

"About 15 minutes in the sunlight during peak hours a few times per week is sufficient for most people to get enough vitamin D production," she said. "People with darker skin may need longer sun exposure."

As for dietary sources, salmon, tuna, mackerel, beef liver, egg yolk and mushrooms all contain vitamin D, Sandon said.

The new reports appear in the April 1 issue of BMJ.

More information

For more about vitamin D, try the Harvard School of Public Health.

SOURCES: Naveed Sattar, professor, metabolic medicine, University of Glasgow, Scotland; Lona Sandon, R.D., assistant professor, nutrition, University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center at Dallas; April 1, 2014, statement, Council for Responsible Nutrition; April 1, 2014, BMJ

Related Items
Daily News Feed
  Health Tip: Signs That You Have a Broken Hip
  Health Tip: Identify Symptoms of a Sprained Wrist
  Backpack Safety Tips for Back to School
  Ruling Out Unneeded Ankle X-Rays for Kids
  Calcium Plus Vitamin D Won't Cure Joint Pain, Study Finds
  Vitamin D Deficiency Often Seen in Traumatic Bone Breaks
  ER Visits Common After Seniors' Surgery, Study Finds
  Health Tip: Signs That You've Sprained a Hip
  Little Benefit Seen in Repeat Bone-Density Testing
  No Sign That Vitamin D Supplements Help Aging Bones: Study
  Ladies, Take 5 Steps to Avoid Osteoporosis
  Treating Rheumatoid Arthritis Early May Cut Damaging Effects
  Obesity Is Driving Surge in Knee Replacements, Study Finds
  New Ligament Discovered in Human Knee
  Exercise May Help Breast Cancer Survivors Battle Bone Loss
  Bone Doctors May Miss Signs of Domestic Abuse, Survey Finds
  Nail-Gun Injuries on the Rise Among Construction Workers
  Timely Surgery Tied to Better Outcomes After Hip Fracture
  Drinking Milk as Teens Might Not Protect Men's Bones, Study Suggests
  Rheumatoid Arthritis Patients See Big Boost in Quality of Life
  Exercise Might Ease Joint Pain Caused by Breast Cancer Drugs
  Vitamin D Supplements Won't Help Prevent Disease: Review
  Bones Benefit From Exercise After Breast Cancer, Study Finds
  Low Vitamin B-12 Levels Tied to Bone Fractures in Older Men
  Some Hip-Replacement Parts Not Proven Safe or Effective: Study
  Avoiding Injury During Winter Sports
  Novel Osteoporosis Drug Could Change Treatment: Study
  Ultramarathoners: How's Their Health?
  Ease Into a Workout Program to Prevent Injuries
  Certain Childhood Fractures May Signal Low Bone Density: Study
  Shoulders Take a Pounding in High School Football
  Despite New Rules, Injuries Still Costly for NHL, Study Finds
  Most Crash Victims Don't Plan to Sue: Study
  Good Marriages Might Be Good for More Than a Man's Heart
  Hormone Therapy May Cut Risk of Repeat Joint Replacement Surgery in Women
  Shoulder Replacement May Help for Severe Rheumatoid Arthritis
  Heavy Kids May Suffer Worse Elbow Fractures
  After Hip Fracture, Home Exercise Program May Boost Recovery
  Walking May Help Older Men Sidestep Hip Fractures
  'Tommy John' Surgery Gets Major League Pitchers Back on the Mound
  Hip Replacement Safe for Patients in Their 90s, Study Finds
  New Knees, Hips May Also Help the Heart
  Will You Need Knee Replacement? Maybe Your Hand Can Tell You
  Health Tip: Maintaining Healthy Joints
  Knee Pain May Not Be Helped by Glucosamine
  Knee Ligament Tears Don't Permanently Sideline Most College Football Players
  Smokers' Broken Bones May Heal Less Quickly: Study
  Knee Surgery May Put Kids at Higher Risk for Future Arthritis
  Exercise in Youth Boosts Bone Strength Later: Study
  CT Scans Might Help Diagnose Gout in Some Cases
  Teens' Screen Time May Affect Their Bone Health: Study
  Drinking Milk May Slow Knee Arthritis in Women, Study Finds
  Health Tip: Reducing Your Risk of Stress Fractures
  Training Programs Protect Young Athletes From ACL Tears: Report
  Osteoporosis Drugs' Long-Term Use Needs More Research: FDA
  Knee Replacement Surgeries Rising With Obesity Rates
  Delaying Kid's Knee Surgery Could Be a Bad Play, Study Finds
  Blood Thinners May Not Be Needed for Kids' Back Surgery
Adult Diseases and Conditions
  Avascular Necrosis
  Bone Disorders
  Diagnostic Procedures for Bone Disorders
  Home Page - Bone Disorders
  Online Resources - Bone Disorders
  Topic Index - Bone Disorders
  Treatments for Bone Disorders
  Benign Bone Tumors
  Common Orthopedic Disorders
  Orthopedic Conditions
Pediatric Diseases and Conditions
  Orthopedic Problems