Health Encyclopedia

 

Health Encyclopedia Home



Counseling With HIV Testing May Not Help Prevent Future STDs

Counseling With HIV Testing May Not Help Prevent Future STDs

TUESDAY, Oct. 22 (HealthDay News) -- Contrary to what experts have believed, briefly counseling people who take a rapid HIV test on how to reduce their risk for sexually transmitted diseases (STDs) is not effective, a new study shows.

Counseling for these at-risk patients did not reduce the incidence of STDs up to six months after patients were tested for HIV, the study found. A more focused approach to providing information at the time of testing may be needed, the authors said, since counseling requires valuable resources of time, money and personnel.

"Overall, these study findings lend support for reconsidering the role of counseling as an essential adjunct to HIV testing," study author Lisa Metsch, at Columbia University's Mailman School of Public Health, and colleagues wrote in the Oct. 23 issue of the Journal of the American Medical Association.

"This inference is further buttressed by the additional costs associated with counseling at the time of testing: Without evidence of effectiveness, counseling cannot be considered an efficient use of resources," they added.

In the United States alone, about 50,000 new HIV infections occur every year, according to a journal news release. The U.S. Preventive Services Task Force recently recommended that all people aged between 15 and 65 be screened for HIV (which causes AIDS).

The researchers randomly assigned about 5,000 patients treated at nine STI clinics in the United States to receive either brief patient-centered HIV risk-reduction counseling along with a rapid HIV test, or the rapid HIV test with information only and no risk-reduction counseling.

Patients who were counseled received advice on their specific high-risk behaviors and concrete steps they could take to reduce their risk for STDs. The researchers assessed STDs among the patients when the study began and again six months after they had their HIV test.

Both men and women were tested for gonorrhea, chlamydia, syphilis, genital herpes and HIV, along with Trichomonas testing for women.

During the study, the STD incidence was 12.3 percent in the counseling group and 11.1 percent in the information-only group. The researchers noted that their findings were consistent at all nine STI clinics and after taking into account the patients' age, sex, race and ethnicity.

However, counseling is vital for patients who are indeed found to have HIV, the researchers emphasized.

"Post-test counseling for persons testing HIV-positive remains essential, both for addressing psychological needs and for providing and ensuring follow-through with medical care and support," they wrote. "A more focused approach to providing information at the time of testing may allow clinics to use resources more efficiently to conduct universal testing, potentially detecting more HIV cases earlier and linking and engaging HIV-infected people in care."

More information

The U.S. Department of Health and Human Services has more about sexually transmitted diseases.

SOURCE: Journal of the American Medical Association, news release, Oct. 22, 2013

 
Related Items
Wellness Library
  What You Need to Know About AIDS
  HIV Prevention Is Still Important
Content Type 134
  HIV/AIDS and Skin Conditions
  Dealing with Discrimination When You Have HIV
  When You’re HIV-Positive: What to Say
  Disorders of the Immune System
  AIDS-Related Malignancies
  Preventing Opportunistic Infections in HIV/AIDS
Drug Reference
  Somatrem, Recombinant, rh-GH
  Tipranavir
  Fosamprenavir
  Emtricitabine; Tenofovir
  Abacavir; Lamivudine, 3TC
  Darunavir
  Efavirenz; Emtricitabine; Tenofovir
  Maraviroc
  Raltegravir
  Etravirine
Quizzes
  HIV/AIDS Quiz
  HIV/AIDS and Seniors Quiz
Daily News Feed
  Researchers Describe 1st 'Functional Cure' of HIV in Baby
  Survival Picture No Better for Patients With HIV-Related Lymphoma: Study
  Rapid Test Detects HIV-1 and HIV-2 Antibodies and HIV-1 Antigen
  New Drug Approved to Treat HIV-1
  HIV Patients Get a Mental Lift From Exercise, Study Finds
  Early Course of HIV Therapy May Give Infants a Break From Drugs
  U.S. Circumcision Rates Drop by 10 Percent: CDC
  For Uninfected Partner, Antiretroviral Drugs May Shield Against HIV
  'Intensified' Global Effort Needed to Further Cut Child Deaths: Report
  Nail Fungus Drug Might Help Against HIV, Study Suggests
  AIDS Virus in Cats Might Help Human Vaccine Effort, Study Hints
  Meds That Prevent HIV Infection Don't Spur Risky Behavior: Study
  Immune Protein Found to Block HIV Spread in Some People
  Scientists Uncover Breast Milk's Potential Secret Weapon Against HIV
  Some 'High-Risk' Kidneys May Be Safe for Organ Transplant: Study
  Big Strides in Battle Against Pediatric AIDS
  Mother-Daughter Team Preaches the Gospel of HIV Prevention
  Child 'Cured' of HIV Remains Free of Virus, Doctors Report
  Early HIV Treatment a Win-Win, Researchers Report
  HIV Resistance Mapped by Gene Researchers
  Bisexual Men Aren't at Greater HIV Risk: Review
  Talking Openly With Partner Linked to HIV Testing in Teens
  New Clues to How Long-Term Drug Therapy Keeps HIV at Bay
  Multivitamins May Help Fight HIV Progression, Study Suggests
  Unprotected Sex On the Rise Among U.S. Gay Men, CDC Says
  New HIV Strain May Move to AIDS More Quickly: Study
  Taking Drug to Prevent HIV Doesn't Seem to Encourage Risk-Taking
  Abused Women Vulnerable to Unsafe Sex Practices
  Many Young Americans With HIV Delay Treatment: Study
  Only 1 in 3 HIV-Infected Black Americans Gets Effective Treatment: Study
  Higher HIV Infection Rates Seen in Mental Health Patients: Study
  Kids' Checkups Should Include Cholesterol, Depression Tests, Doctors Say
  Kids Born With HIV May Face Heart Risks Later, Study Suggests
  Long-Acting HIV Drug May Offer Better Protection Against Infection
  Gene Therapy for Controlling HIV Shows Early Promise
  Doctors Cautiously Optimistic About 'Cure' for HIV-Infected Babies
  Vaginal Gel Might Prevent HIV Hours After Exposure
  HIV Transmission Between Women Rare, But Possible: CDC
  Hepatitis C Patients With HIV May Face Higher Risk of Liver Disease
  Study Adds to Signs Linking HIV to Heart Trouble
  HIV-Positive Inmates Benefit From Drug Treatment, Study Says
  Driving Ability May Falter With Age in HIV-Positive Adults
  Scientists Map DNA of Deadly Fungus
  Slightly Higher Risk of Birth Defects Seen in Pregnant Women on HIV Drugs
  CDC Urges Anti-HIV Pill for People at High Risk of Infection
  Kids More Likely Than Adults To Be Resistant to HIV Meds: Study
  Many Unaware of Their HIV Status Until It's Advanced
  Study: Common HIV Drug May Boost Suicide Risk
  HIV Prevention Drug Truvada Might Lower Genital Herpes Risk, Too
  HIV Patients Less Likely to Get Cancer Treatment: Study
  Mississippi Girl Thought Cured of HIV Shows Signs of Infection
  AIDS Epidemic May Be Subsiding: Report
  Those With HIV Living Longer, International Study Finds
  Many Sexually Active U.S. Teens Not Tested for HIV: CDC
  HIV Diagnoses Down in U.S., Except for Young Gay Males: CDC
  Animal Experiments Shed Light on HIV's Ability to Hide
  Scientists Snipped HIV Out of Human DNA
Adult Diseases and Conditions
  HIV and AIDS
Pediatric Diseases and Conditions
  Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome (AIDS)/Human Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV)
  AIDS/HIV in Children